"I may disagree with what
you have to say, but I shall defend, to the death, your right
to say it." --Voltaire
Ah, it's good to be back in the
warmth and sunshine of Spring, eh? The Dixie Chicks are back
too with a new single. If you haven't heard yet, it's called
"Not Ready to Make Nice." Now, I can't stand cuntry
music. Hate it, actually. In fact, it's one of the very few
rifts between my girlfriend and me. And this song tears that
rift a new asshole.
Three years ago, when our esteemed
President first took his Coked-Up-Cowboy act on an International
tour, the Dixie Chicks were on one as well. They were in England
when the lead singer made her opinion of the lead American quite
clear: "Just so you know, we're ashamed the President of
the United States is from Texas." All Hell broke loose
in Dixieland. County stations stopped playing their music and
videos, fans became rabid, rallying to destroy the group's tapes,
CDs and concert tickets, and writing threatening letters.
The singer apologized to Bush
for being disrespectful to him, and asserted that she was NOT
Un-American, but was a concerned American Mother upset that
Bush rushed to war, putting soldiers' lives at risk. Now, they're
not apologizing anymore, and they're pissed about what everyone
said about them. Pretty ballsy, huh? I'm rather impressed. Not
only have they alienated most of their fan base with their statements,
their new single, recorded in more Pop fashion than Country,
tells the former fans that THEY'RE the ones that need to apologize.
Yee-ha!
When we first started discussing
this debacle, my Luve asked "why do you give a shit? You
hate country music." Because it's not about the Music,
it's about the Message. A singer expressed her opinion during
a concert. Because it was not shared with their audience, they
were banished from the industry. Granted, I agree with the Chicks'
assessment of Gee Dubya, but that is immaterial. There are much
bigger issues at hand namely Freedom of Speech and Patriotism.
Most argue that this is a matter
of Patriotism: you never badmouth the President on foreign soil.
If that is the core belief, as it is with my Wonderful Will-Be-Wife,
then that's all there is to it. It's a principle that is either
agreed upon or not, but it's just an idea. Like Religion: those
that believe always agree with you, and those that don't, won't
understand. Like me.
Patriotism isn't a BAD thing.
But, three years ago, our country slipped from the manic Patriotism
that erupted after 9/11 into Nationalism, the belief that our
country is better than every other, and we should impose our
ways on them. Exposing that stance isn't the same as hating
America, as some argue, it's just disrespectful to Nationalists.
Think: the lone German bad mouthing the Nazis.
Hey, I'm a Guinea from Jersey;
I know the rules about Respect. If you watch The Sopranos, you
do too. You never disrespect the Family.
But if Tony decided he was going
to send Chrissy and company into NY to tear shit up, capture
a Boss, and impose their values on a Chinese Family, it would
start a Holy War. If done under the guise of Spreading Freedom,
everyone would see right through it and try to fight it. John
and the boys from NY would be up in arms; Tony's own Capos would
be crazed. And you can bet the Bada Bing that there would be
a LOT of disrespect towards Tony.
So what does this all come down
to? Hurt feelings over a show of disrespect? A celebrity being
"unpatriotic?" Or is this something else? Is all the
hoopla over the assumption that all country singers are supposed
to be unabashedly Republican supporters?
I don't think this argument has
anything to do with Patriotism. I think country fans are just
angry that a band they listen to has a different political opinion
than the rest of the sheep.
"Sheep." A group of
people who believe what the person next to them believes, never
straying from the group, and expecting anyone like them, or
that they like, to do the same. You can spot sheep by the following
the sounds of regurgitating talk points and the bashing of anyone
who doesn't spew those points.
Random thought: if Eddie Vedder
spouted off in Italy that "George Bush is a Muppet controlled
by a crucifix and Dick Chaney's hand up his ass," not a
single Red Stater would protest Pearl Jam. This isn't about
Patriotism; it's about perceived betrayal of fans of country
music, not of America. The Dixie Chicks hurt fans' feelings.
If Patriotism was the true ideal,
Love of Country would mean the American ideal of Free Speech
would be protected. It's not a Right that gets suspended because
we're at war, or because the opinion expressed is unpopular
or criticizes the government. It's not a Right that we apply
or deny on a whim. It is what defines this country as a Bastion
of Freedom.
Under our President, we're fighting
for other people to have Freedom. In this country, we're taking
those freedoms away. To support this President is to support
his assault on the Freedom of Privacy with unwarranted wire
taps and his condemning segments of our population to a second-class
citizenship of less-than-equal rights, be they Minorities recovering
from lost lives after Katrina, Immigrants trying to live here,
or Gays just trying to Live.
As Americans, we should be protecting
those rights. We should celebrate the Voices of Dissent shouting
that our leaders have gone astray and abandoned OUR rights.
The people that founded this country were Voices of Dissent.
I respect the Dixie Chicks for
standing their ground in the face of adversity, for telling
the blind and angry who abandoned them and sometimes threatened
them, that THEY are the ones who should apologize. As Americans,
we owe them that apology.
get.kra.z@gmail.com.
Kra-Z is an Artist. 'Nuff
said. He lives and plays in Las Vegas, but his heart is still
on stage at the Jersey Shore. See his work @
artgonekra-z.com